Looking Beyond COVID-19

Government-Mandated Recession — Bigger Government — Bigger Companies — Big Political Change? — Opening the Economy?

Federal and State Mandated Recession

COVID-19 led to a government — Federal and state-mandated recession to mitigate the virus. This commentary reviews how the government-mandated recession will likely increase government involvement in the economy, lead to market leaders further increasing their domination, result in possible political change in Washington, and change investment focus as the economy opens.

Service Industry Normally Buffers Economic Downturn — Devastated by this Recession

Typically, the service industry (over 70% of GDP) buffers cyclical declines experienced by manufacturers (11% of GDP) and other cyclical industries. The government-mandated recession truly brought many service industries, such as restaurants, entertainment, and tourism, to a halt. A survey from Morning Consults shows the difficult path faced by these industries as the economy opens up and they resume operations (see Figure 1). With this near-term headwind, selective investments in product manufacturers and distributors may prove more attractive than services.

Figure 1

Consumer Comfort with Resuming Activities — Two Week Trend

Source: Morning Consults

COVID Recession Will Force Service Companies to Improve Productivity

To overcome their industry headwinds, service-oriented companies will likely find new and better ways to reach their customers. If correct, one outcome of this pandemic could result in improved productivity for various service industries. With its importance to US GDP, improved service productivity would contribute importantly to overall US economic growth rates.

Greater Market Dominance of the Largest Firms

The recession will likely cause weaker capitalized firms to fall back further competitively. As a result, either market-dominant firms will acquire weaker competitors and suppliers, or they will disappear — most likely disappear. In either case, the “bigs” will further exert their market dominance. In this difficult economic period, investors must carefully determine whether so-called value investments can either regain business traction or become an attractive acquisition candidate. If not, in this difficult economic environment, there may not be sufficient economic “oxygen” to sustain their life.

Big Techs Dominate Equity Markets—Another Path for Investors?

Dispersion of Returns — Have vs. Have Nots — a Reversal?

According to a recent Goldman Sachs study, while the S&P 500 index remains roughly 17% below its all-time high, the typical stock trades about 28% below that high. Very simply, five stocks — big tech — in the S&P 500 now account for approximately 20% of the index. This broad dispersion of returns between the haves and have nots argues for considering a possible narrowing of this difference. Opening the economy could produce just such a change.

A Reversal — Use Equal-Weight S&P 500 Index

One way to take advantage of that possible reversal would use the equal-weighted instead of the cap-weighted S&P 500 index. Historically, the equal-weighted S&P 500 index outperformed the cap-weighted index by over 1% annually (see Figure 2). However, since 2017, the cap-weighted index outperformed based on the strength of tech stocks (see Figures 2 and 3). By using the equal-weighted index, investors would then benefit from a likely broader recovery of stocks when the economy begins to show improvement.

Figure 2

Source: Index Investment Strategy, S&P Dow Jones Indices LOLC, and FactSet

Figure 3

S&P 500 Equal-Weighted Index One-Day Performance to S&P 500 Index

Source: Bloomberg, WSJ/Daily Shot

Virus Heaviest Impact on Half of GDP

Opening the economy will vary by region and state. While many states experienced a modest impact from the virus, some metropolitan areas felt a heavy rate of infections and, tragically, deaths. According to Quill Intelligence, half of GDP comes from less than 3% of US counties. Despite that small percentage, because of their population densities and other variables, they accounted for 61% of COVID-19 cases in this country.

States May Gain Economic Advantage by Opening Earlier

The timing for opening these key counties will importantly determine the strength and speed of our economic recovery. The most heavily affected regions will likely open slower than other regions. Longer-term, to stimulate their growth, these counties will undoubtedly seek new approaches to overcome economic handicaps exposed by the virus. At the same time, those states that can safely open up earlier and more broadly will gain an economic advantage. Commercial real estate represents one industry that will likely see the most significant impact from the pandemic on densely populated counties. Perhaps it will result in some shifts to office space in their surrounding suburbs.

Recession in Presidential Year Becomes a Political Event

A recession in a presidential election year turns an economic event into a political one. The current economic difficulties could lead to a possible change in the White House as well as returning one-party control to both houses of Congress. History argues for such a change. Quoting from a recent article in Newsweek, “since 1900, only one president has won re-election with a recession occurring sometime in the last two years of their first term — William McKinley.” Admittedly, the incumbent demonstrates an ability to overcome consensus expectations, as the 2016 election showed. The speed of the economic recovery will likely heavily influence the election result.

Change in White House and One-Party Congress Would Significantly Expand Government’s Role in the Economy

With the uncertain speed of the recovery, it seems too early to speculate on the rate of change a new administration would bring to current and new Federal programs. Substantial increases in the Federal deficit now taking place will likely restrain any major new programs. However, higher tax rates, particularly on corporations and higher-income individuals, will mark the future — no matter which party gains control. A new world in Washington would also resume regulatory expansion. Overall, a new administration will likely significantly expand the government’s role in the economy.

Investment Conclusions

“V” Shaped Equity Bounce – Commodity Market Decline

Equity markets made a “V” shaped rebound. The economic recovery will not likely match that optimism. At that same time, commodities, and particularly oil, showed a historic drop. The different performance between both markets reflects their investment perspectives. Equity markets tend to discount the longer-term outlook for industries and companies. In comparison, commodity markets reflect immediate supply and demand forces in spot or current prices — not the future.

“Kitchen Sink” Earnings Year for Many Companies

So far, roughly twenty percent of S&P 500 companies have suspended guidance — likely, more will follow. A good percentage of companies will use this year as a “kitchen sink” year by writing off their past mistakes. The bottom line, this year’s earnings outlook for most companies will give little basis for using traditional stock valuation approaches. Companies will also likely write down their inventory valuations as much as auditors will permit. By doing so, this will help boost 2021 earnings.

2021 Rebound

Hopefully, the economy will recover sufficiently so that 2021’s first-half earnings compare favorably to this year’s sharp decline. The economic outlook for the second half of 2021 depends on consumers and their “psyche.” Therefore, recovery of consumer spending will depend on successful therapeutic and vaccine developments as well as confidence in testing programs.

Portfolio Recommendation

We approach financial markets with cautious optimism. Part of that optimism reflects our faith in the dynamism and ingenuity of American business and workers to overcome hurdles brought by the pandemic. At the same time, our caution reflects the unsteady path the economy faces to regain stable growth. With that, our investment recommendation remains 40% equities, 35% alternatives, and 25% fixed income. Reaching that recommended equity asset mix leads to rebuilding equity positions in high-quality companies with strong balance sheets selling at what will likely prove attractive prices. How fast each investor rebuilds depends on their own comfort to do so. In the case of fixed income, we recommended short-term credits to preserve capital, and that continues to be our recommendation.

First Capital Advisors Group, LLC is a federally registered investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The oral and written communications of an adviser provide you with information about which you determine to hire or retain an adviser. First Capital Advisors Group, LLC, form ADV part 2A & 2B can be obtained by written request directly to: First Capital Advisors Group, LLC 512 East Township Toad, 5 Valley Plaza, Bluebell, PA 19422. This is prepared for informational purposes only. It does not address specific investment objectives nor is the content intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. Although taken from reliable sources, First Capital Advisors cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information received from third parties.
5/1/20
« Previous